skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Amazing experience every time I love this place one of my amazing friends works here: Ali Best spicy
Amazing experience every time I love this place one of my amazing friends works here: Ali Best spicy margarita I've ever had! Love this place ... read more
Gisele U. via yelp.com - Aug 30, 2021
Food is ridiculously good. Service excellent. A staple of the North Shore ... read more
Johan Chabrel via google.com - Aug 29, 2021
We booked an outdoor table. Shortly after enjoying our delicious cocktails, it started to pour. The
We booked an outdoor table. Shortly after enjoying our delicious cocktails, it started to pour. The manager personally came outside and rearranged our seating under the awning taking pains to adjust umbrellas to keep us dry. Loved my strawberry basil margarita and my husband enjoyed cucumber martini. Food was delicious as well. Would ... read more
persnicketygurl via tripadvisor.com - Aug 22, 2021
Service is always exceptional, food is amazing and always worth the wait. We had a server, Daria, wh
Service is always exceptional, food is amazing and always worth the wait. We had a server, Daria, who was super attentive ... read more
Tessa M. via yelp.com - Aug 18, 2021
For a totally awesome meal - Brass Rail in Locust Valley - worth the trip. Incredible creative menu
For a totally awesome meal - Brass Rail in Locust Valley - worth the trip. Incredible creative menu by an amazing young CIA chef and does not break the bank. Beautiful romantic atmosphere and the food is the BEST I have had on L.I. Easily competitive with top chef restaurants in NYC. You MUST try for a fabulous meal!!! Here is Kent M ... read more
Arlene M. via yelp.com - Jul 21, 2021
Food was delicious, staff was very friendly and the dessert......they had me at peach cobbler!!!
Reggie Butt via google.com - Jul 14, 2021
Loved it!!!
Donna gail via google.com - Jun 28, 2021
Terrific food ... read more
DAVID LOEWENSTEIN via google.com - May 28, 2021
Service was awesome. Food was excellent ... read more
Bruce Canner via google.com - May 28, 2021
"Charming restaurant, excellent service and terrific small plates Ecletic menu." ... read more
alicia vaughan via google.com - May 28, 2021
Four of us had dinner yesterday 4/14/21 and it was excellent in every aspect . We go to the Rail oft
Four of us had dinner yesterday 4/14/21 and it was excellent in every aspect . We go to the Rail often and for years, it never disappoints. Even in the pandemic they adapt and produce what is expected.
Robert C. via yelp.com - May 15, 2021
Great menu and friendly staff! So cozy and nice with a long bar. You wouldn't know from the outside being that it's in a plaza, but it's a nice, gastropub with dim, lively atmosphere with high ceilings and mirrors everywhere. Not divey at all like I assumed. Really enjoyed my mixed green salad with pine nuts & truffle vinaigrette ... read more
Kim Nguyen via google.com - Apr 28, 2021
Always count on great service and very good food. I like to hang at the bar and eat their Steak. Very reliable. Usually a local crowd ... read more
John Sodano via google.com - Apr 28, 2021
Food is very good..price is high, ... read more
Keith Krause via google.com - Mar 28, 2021
I like rock shrimp ... read more
Aidan Martone via google.com - Feb 28, 2021
Best bartender! Best burger : Jalapeño- cheddar burger. My go-to dish is chicken paillaird. My famil
Best bartender! Best burger : Jalapeño- cheddar burger. My go-to dish is chicken paillaird. My family loves the French dip. Best dessert - key lime pie.
Maria C. via yelp.com - Jan 30, 2021
Brass Rail is an all rounder good restaurant. That being said a fresh updated menu would be so welco
Brass Rail is an all rounder good restaurant. That being said a fresh updated menu would be so welcome. Similar to most of the better restaurants on The North Shore The Brass Rail has an ol' faithful neighborhood clientele. The menu remains the same. We would love to see some of the New Brooklyn food make its debut on the island. Com ... read more
Seema G. via yelp.com - Jan 11, 2021
Long enjoyed this restaurant - particularly for the fish and beer selection on tap. They have been a
Long enjoyed this restaurant - particularly for the fish and beer selection on tap. They have been a saving grace for delicious take-out for the family during Covid. (both healthy or a more indulgent treat - your pick) ... read more
Drew W. via yelp.com - Jan 7, 2021
Great spot with a nice dark ambiance, menu with lots of options and great food. The lobster Mac is t
Great spot with a nice dark ambiance, menu with lots of options and great food. The lobster Mac is too good.
Christina D. via yelp.com - Nov 7, 2020
The halibut was one of the best meals I've had in years.
Ted Mantle via google.com - Oct 28, 2020
Stopped in to The Brass Rail for lunch, we were working in the neighborhood for a client and this wa
Stopped in to The Brass Rail for lunch, we were working in the neighborhood for a client and this was a local recomendation so we decided to stop in. I was happy to see that this restaurant is owned by the same people who run The Wild Goose in Port Washington, which I had a great dinner date at a few months back. We came in for an ea ... read more
Alex H. via yelp.com - Sep 21, 2020
Great spot for dinner. We felt safe and enjoyed the food. Wonderful rack of lamb and veal chop speci
Great spot for dinner. We felt safe and enjoyed the food. Wonderful rack of lamb and veal chop special. Peter the waiter was so nice and helpful.
Shana M. via yelp.com - Sep 12, 2020
Always a great meal at the Brass Rail Fish was great , steak excellent The lobster bisque is the bes
Always a great meal at the Brass Rail Fish was great , steak excellent The lobster bisque is the best Excellent service and ambience ... read more
Victor K. via yelp.com - Sep 5, 2020
Lobster bisque, lobster Mac and cheese, rock shrimp, start with those 3 and then enjoy the steak ah
Lobster bisque, lobster Mac and cheese, rock shrimp, start with those 3 and then enjoy the steak ah piorfeteferre or however it's spelt and pronounced ... read more
Keith H. via yelp.com - Aug 20, 2020
Nice eatery nestled in the cozy village of Locust Valley. Awesome antique bar and old world decor. T
Nice eatery nestled in the cozy village of Locust Valley. Awesome antique bar and old world decor. The bar has a story. It's from the 1800s! Great experience. Service was good. Loved their sweet chili glazed calamari appetizer that comes with coleslaw. The bar menu wings were also good. For entrees we had the pad thai, sirloin burger ... read more
Ner A. via yelp.com - Aug 17, 2020
Food was delicious...
Stephen Azzarello (sjazz1) via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Best burgers ... read more
Rosa Villatoro via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Food was wonderful, 4 of us had salmon. Ambiance was very good.
E Hogan via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Nice brunch,very quiet,inexpensive.
Kelly Cavanagh via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Always a 10 ... read more
Tony Gusta via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Superb vibes and very friendly service. The menu was crisp and enchanting. Will absolutely recommend this spot to anyone. Fair rates and big meals. Keep up the great work.
Mark Ferguson via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Nice atmosphere. Good service provided by Toni Ann. Very nice mixed salad. Delicious roasted cauliflower soup! My friend had the blackened mahi mahi, very good. My husband had fish and chips moist and tender. Highly recommend.
Sharon Goodman via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Great date spot. Sophisticated but unpretentious dishes.Great local beer list,specialty cocktails and very attentive staff round out a wonderful location. Located in a very interesting little hamlet. Cant wait to go back!
Chuck McDonald via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
two days ago was the first time we came to that magnificent restaurant. But It is surely not the last time. We passed a splendid evening with the generous service, with the finest meal and fine drinks and with the honest pay. We will no doubt return there again.
Robert Lane via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Creative and sophisticated menu featuring well-prepared, high quality food all presented by a well-trained professional staff. Highly recommend.
Andrew Rivkin via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
We frequent this restaurant. Usually the service is perfect ... tonight we were first served the wrong salad and then we had to wait a very long time for our entrees. The food is always delicious here though.
Teresa I via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
Great food. Nice atmosphere ... read more
Michael RinoRemover via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
First time eating at a restaurant since NY started allowing outdoor seating, and the Brass Rail cert
First time eating at a restaurant since NY started allowing outdoor seating, and the Brass Rail certainly did not disappoint. They had about five tables, all with respect to social distancing guidelines. Servers were very attentive and abided by all guidelines, masks and gloves for everyone working. Menus were the one's you would nor ... read more
Austin R. via yelp.com - Jun 13, 2020
Love Brass Rail. The food is excellent. Their team is amazing, especially Susan. She is always smili
Love Brass Rail. The food is excellent. Their team is amazing, especially Susan. She is always smiling & singing. Energy is important for a restaurant and Hers is amazing. My 4yr old son loves her. I really appreciate, the family style specials and their quick jump to action to be there for the community!! Thank you Brass Rail.
Christina H. via yelp.com - Jun 5, 2020
During this pandemic, I miss going out to eat and really, how much pizza can you feed your family? W
During this pandemic, I miss going out to eat and really, how much pizza can you feed your family? We're been to The Brass Rail on multiple occasions, but never ordered take out. Well, last Saturday we decided to order a nice takeout meal. It was, in a word, EXCELLENT. The packaging alone of everything was so well thought out! A burg ... read more
Kris D. via yelp.com - May 26, 2020
An old time favorite! The food, Service and ambience is always good. You really can't go wrong with
An old time favorite! The food, Service and ambience is always good. You really can't go wrong with anything you order here. The small plates are not really small and the dessert is delicious. If you haven't been here before it's a must try & you won't stop coming back.
Nisha P. via yelp.com - Feb 28, 2020
10/10 would go back at least once a month. Amazing menu. Seafood gumbo app was to die for. Coconut/l
10/10 would go back at least once a month. Amazing menu. Seafood gumbo app was to die for. Coconut/lime dream martini was a little too strong, but the red sangria was made perfectly & super delicious, fruity, fresh! Oysters were fresh, amazing quality what a hidden gem!!! Really enjoyed my time here and the atmosphere. Just wish ther ... read more
Sheri S. via yelp.com - Feb 23, 2020
Went for lunch on a Saturday. Food and atmosphere were fantastic. I had a burger which was cooked as
Went for lunch on a Saturday. Food and atmosphere were fantastic. I had a burger which was cooked as ordered and absolutely delicious. The shoestring fries were cut very thin and cooked to perfection. The decor was was early 1900's and reminiscent of the Brass Rail in Hoboken NJ. Service was a bit slow but attentive. Overall, very go ... read more
Mike P. via yelp.com - Feb 9, 2020
The food was absolutely delicious. We had lamb, lobster, clams and linguine, salads and dessert. Eve
The food was absolutely delicious. We had lamb, lobster, clams and linguine, salads and dessert. Everything was done just right and presented well. Our waiter was excellent.
Peter S via tripadvisor.com - Sep 4, 2019
Delicious burgers ... read more
Gena Marsico via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
You get what you pay for ... read more
k k via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
Excellent atmosphere, great drinks, fantastic food and awesome friends.
Madison Ave via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
Excellent food, even better drinks ... read more
katie baiata via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
Great bartender. Diverse menu in price and selections. Food and service was great!
Gary Leider via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
Great food ... read more
Will Rubens via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
Very good food , love their burger ... read more
Frank F via google.com - Jul 28, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire